The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Supreme Court prediction markets fight may hinge on narrow sports carve-out

Lawyers tell SBC Americas the Supreme Court could draw a line between sports contracts with hedging value and manipulation-prone props rather than issuing a blanket ruling.

Exterior of the U.S. Supreme Court building, where a prediction markets sports case is pending
AI-generated illustration

The jurisdictional dispute over prediction market sports contracts has reached the doorstep of the U.S. Supreme Court, with attorneys telling SBC Americas that any eventual ruling is likely to split the difference rather than settle the industry's fate outright.

New Jersey petitioned the court on 2 September to review an April ruling by the Third Circuit Court of Appeals that favoured Kalshi in Flaherty v. KalshiEX. The justices are weighing whether to take that case or a related one brought by Robinhood and Crypto.com out of the Ninth Circuit.

Troutman Pepper Locke partner Stephen Piepgrass said the dispute is closer to Supreme Court review than at any point so far, but cautioned that substantial procedural steps remain. "We are on the doorstep. Obviously, the door still has to open, and then the whole briefing and oral argument," he told SBC Americas. "We are closer than ever, but it will still take time."

Kalshi founder Tarek Mansour said on the Reuters Econ World podcast that he also expects the case to reach the Supreme Court, though he declined to forecast how the justices would rule.

Piepgrass stressed that the case before the courts covers only sports event contracts, not prediction markets as a whole. "Often lost in the public dialogue is that the issue before the courts is narrow, and it's only prediction market sports trades," he said, adding that early predictions the markets would be banned outright have not materialised.

The core legal question is whether sports event contracts count as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act, placing them under the exclusive jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or whether they function as sports bets that states and tribal regulators can police. Piepgrass said both sides tend to argue the issue in stark terms that obscure how much grey area the justices must work through.

Former Senator Chris Dodd filed an amicus brief in August backing New Jersey's position, a filing with particular weight given that Kalshi's swap argument rests on the Dodd-Frank Act, the 2010 law bearing his name that amended the Commodity Exchange Act and handed the CFTC exclusive authority over swaps. Dodd wrote that "Congress did not set out to authorize nationwide sports betting through derivatives markets or displace decades of state and tribal primacy over gaming regulation."

Former CFTC Chair Gary Gensler, who worked with Congress on Dodd-Frank, also filed a brief supporting New Jersey. Testifying before Congress 54 times as chairman, he said, sports betting was never raised as a topic, and he added that the agency never asked for the resources needed to function as a national gambling regulator. "If Dodd-Frank had preempted the states and tribes on sports betting, it would have been one of the biggest stories about Dodd-Frank at the time. But nobody ever mentioned it," Gensler wrote.

New Jersey's petition is supported by eleven amicus briefs in total, including those from Dodd and Gensler.

TurnKey Family Office founder and former CFTC special counsel Peter Sanchez Guarda told SBC Americas the court could permit some sports contracts while barring others rather than issuing a single verdict. "There could be a decision that permits some types of sports contracts in prediction markets where there are legitimate hedging and price discovery features and bans others," he said.

Sanchez Guarda pointed to championship outcomes as an example of contracts with defensible commercial ties, noting that a Super Bowl win affects merchandise sales, broadcast rights pricing and stadium ticket sales. He contrasted that with in-game props, such as bets on individual pitches, which he said carry fewer such justifications, particularly given the CFTC's Core Principle 3 requirement that traded contracts not be readily susceptible to manipulation.

Piepgrass said the NFL's own amicus brief maps out that kind of middle ground between hedging-driven contracts and manipulation-prone props.

Attorneys expect any definitive Supreme Court ruling to arrive no sooner than summer or autumn 2027, leaving the industry to operate under continued legal uncertainty while the case moves through the review process.