The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Brazil's STF freezes legal challenges to betting ban measure

Brazil's Supreme Federal Court has paused lower-court cases over Provisional Measure 1.394, the decree that halted the country's year-old regulated betting market.

Brazilian flag alongside gavel symbolising the Supreme Federal Court's betting ban ruling
AI-generated illustration

Brazil's Supreme Federal Court (STF) has suspended all lower-court proceedings connected to Provisional Measure 1.394, the decree signed by President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva in late September that banned the country's licensed gambling sector, according to iGaming Business.

The move halts cases brought by operators who had secured injunctions allowing them to briefly resume trading, both of which were subsequently overturned. The STF is instead referring the matter to the full court rather than leaving it to a single justice.

That shift has dampened earlier optimism among operators that Justice Luis Fux might block the measure outright. Ari Celia, director at Brazilian payments company Pay4Fun, told iGB there had been hope Fux would act alone, but "it seems the case became too significant for him to handle alone, so it has been referred to the full court."

Celia described the government's reasoning as politically driven rather than evidence-based. "The current situation is defined by uncertainty," he said, adding that the arguments used to justify the ban had been debunked.

The ban followed years of work to establish a regulated market, which launched on 1 January 2025. Operators paid BRL30 million ($6 million) for a five-year licence alongside substantial tax obligations, and the sector generated almost BRL10 billion in tax revenue during its first year, per iGB.

Within days of Lula's announcement, a lawsuit landed at the STF, brought jointly by the Brazilian Institute of Responsible Gaming and the National Association of Games and Lotteries (ANJL). ANJL president Plínio Lemos Jorge called the decree an "illegal and abrupt measure" and said the reaction across the market was one of "perplexity", warning that Brazil's longstanding reputation for honouring contracts had been undermined by the decision.

Luiz Felipe Maia, founding partner at law firm Maia Yoshiyasu Advogados, argued that the STF's suspension of lower-court cases was itself legally questionable, calling it "basically an unconstitutional decision issued by the Constitutional Court" and noting that the Brazilian Constitution guarantees access to the courts.

Maia also questioned the constitutional basis for the decree itself, which under Brazilian law can only be used in cases of genuine urgency. He pointed out that Lula issued the measure roughly a week before the first round of the presidential election, which he went on to win. "There was no urgency," Maia said, arguing the timing suggested an electoral rather than regulatory motive.

He added that the government had failed to meet obligations under Brazil's Fiscal Responsibility Law, which requires any bill or provisional measure cancelling revenue to identify a replacement source. "There is no study on economic effects, on fiscal effects, on regulatory effects," he said, describing the decree as rushed through ahead of the vote.

A public hearing on the ANJL's case was held before the STF in early November, with stakeholders arguing both sides, though the court has yet to rule. Under Brazil's Constitution, a provisional measure lapses after 60 days unless converted into law by Congress, meaning the decree's ultimate fate is likely to rest with lawmakers as much as judges.