Federal judge rejects Novig's bid to dodge New York gambling law
A New York court has sided with the state attorney general, ruling that Novig's peer-to-peer sports contracts function as ordinary sports bets rather than federally regulated derivatives.

A federal court in New York has refused to shield prediction market operator Novig from the state's gambling laws, concluding that its sports contracts amount to conventional wagers rather than protected financial instruments, Casino.org News reported.
According to Casino.org News, U.S. District Judge Colleen McMahon set out her reasoning in a 35-page opinion, refusing to grant Novig the preliminary injunction it sought against the state's gaming regulators and New York Attorney General Letitia James.
Novig had asked the court to block enforcement, arguing that the federal Commodity Exchange Act pre-empts New York from applying its own sports betting rules to the platform.
The ruling clears the way for the state to pursue enforcement action, leaving Novig with a choice between applying for a New York gambling licence or withdrawing the product from the state. It does not require the company to halt operations elsewhere in the country.
Novig runs a peer-to-peer exchange on which customers trade contracts tied to sporting outcomes instead of betting directly against a bookmaker. Its parent company, Ludlow Exchange LLC, was designated a contract market by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission in June, a status Novig says places its products solely under federal oversight as swaps.
Judge McMahon disagreed. While she accepted that sporting outcomes qualify as events or contingencies under the Commodity Exchange Act, she found they lack the financial or commercial stakes required to make Novig's offerings genuine swaps.
She noted that the platform's point spreads, player props and parlays are functionally the same as products sold by licensed operators such as FanDuel and BetMGM, citing one four-game NFL parlay on Novig that paid out more than 111 times the original stake.
"The Court is not required to disregard common sense—Novig's sports event contracts are sports betting," McMahon wrote.
The judge also pointed out that Novig previously held a Colorado sports betting licence before surrendering it in favour of its current exchange-based structure, treating that history as further evidence of what the contracts actually are.
CFTC's conduct questioned
McMahon reserved particular criticism for the CFTC itself, describing the agency's recent regulatory positioning on sports contracts as inconsistent and questioning whether it had sought to shape the litigation improperly.
She went further on a related matter, suggesting that a separate CFTC order allowing a rival prediction platform to continue operating despite facing legal action "smacks of a collusive effort" to manufacture a conflict with federal law.
McMahon added that even if Novig's contracts were ultimately classified as swaps, federal commodities law would not automatically override New York's long-standing authority to police gambling within its borders.
The decision is not a final judgment in Novig's underlying lawsuit, but it adds another data point to a patchwork of court rulings across the country on how prediction markets built around sports outcomes should be treated under state and federal law.