Judge rejects Novig injunction, rebukes CFTC over NY sports contracts
A federal judge denied Novig's bid to block New York enforcement, ruling its sports contracts are gambling while accusing the CFTC of contradictory and collusive conduct.

A federal judge in New York has denied prediction market operator Novig's request to block state enforcement against its sports event contracts, in a ruling that also took aim at the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's handling of the issue.
U.S. District Court Southern District of New York Judge Colleen McMahon issued the 35-page opinion on 10 November, rejecting Novig's motion for a preliminary injunction against New York Attorney General Letitia James and members of the New York State Gaming Commission, according to SBC Americas.
Novig had sued James and the gaming commission in August, shortly after launching its platform in the state, seeking to pre-empt enforcement action. The company appealed McMahon's ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit immediately after it was issued, the same appellate court that ruled against rival Kalshi in New York earlier this month.
McMahon sided with New York's position that Novig's contracts do not meet the Commodity Exchange Act's definition of a swap and instead amount to unlicensed sports betting. She wrote that the state can insist Novig either secure a gambling licence or stop offering sports contracts within its borders.
The judge cited Novig and its chief executive's own public statements in reaching that conclusion. "Our north star is to be the largest sports betting platform in the world," she quoted them as saying, adding: "The Court is not required to disregard common sense – Novig's sports event contracts are sports betting."
She noted Congress drafted the Commodity Exchange Act to regulate activity such as hedging against corn futures, "not consumers betting on Thursday Night Football," and said that even if the contracts were classed as swaps, federal law would not automatically override New York's gambling statute.
McMahon also dismissed Novig's argument that its peer-to-peer trading model, in which users buy and sell contracts against one another rather than against a house, makes the product fundamentally different from a traditional sports bet. In a footnote, she wrote that Novig makes money "not off the sucker who places a losing bet on a sports event, but by charging two suckers a fee for the privilege of betting against each other on its platform."
She described Novig's offering as functionally identical to wagers available on licensed sportsbooks, writing that "from the perspective of the customer, there is no qualitative difference between Novig's product and FanDuel's traditional sports bet," and that "who is on the other side of the bet is simply not a difference that makes a difference." She pointed out that FanDuel holds licences in 24 states and suggested Novig could pursue the same route.
The opinion was equally critical of the CFTC's own conduct. McMahon said the agency's rulemaking was contradictory, noting its Notice of Proposed Rulemaking treated sports-event contracts as swaps on the same day its Interim Final Rule exempted casino-style products, including sportsbook and casino games, from that classification.
She wrote it was "impossible to escape the conclusion" that ordinary casino transactions would also qualify as swaps under Novig's reading of the law, and that the CFTC's positions "are inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled."
McMahon went further, suggesting the commission's reversal of its long-standing view that sports wagering falls to the states "appears calculated to influence the outcome of the ongoing litigation on this very issue." She separately criticised the CFTC's emergency order directing Kalshi to keep operating in defiance of state orders, according to SBC Americas's reporting of the opinion.