The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Novig sues Ohio over sports event contract crackdown

Novig has taken Ohio's attorney general and casino regulator to federal court, arguing CFTC rulemaking has undercut a recent appeals court win for the state against Kalshi.

Gavel and legal documents representing Novig's federal lawsuit against Ohio regulators
AI-generated illustration

Novig has sued Ohio's attorney general and gaming regulators in federal court, seeking to block enforcement of state sports betting law against its prediction market business, according to SBC Americas.

The complaint, filed on 16 November in the US District Court for the Northern District of Ohio, was brought by Ludlow Exchange LLC, Novig's federally licensed designated contract market. Defendants named include Attorney General Andy Wilson, Ohio Casino Control Commission Interim Executive Director Andromeda Morrison, OCCC Chair Thomas Stickrath and the commission's other commissioners.

Ohio is the seventh state Novig has sued since it began running a near-nationwide prediction market platform in August, joining earlier actions in Massachusetts, Missouri, New Mexico, New York, Washington and Wisconsin. Novig had previously operated as a state-regulated peer-to-peer sportsbook before shifting to its current federally designated model.

The lawsuit follows a cease-and-desist letter the OCCC sent to Novig and nine other companies in early October, which warned of possible criminal action if firms continued offering sports event contracts in Ohio without a state licence. Kalshi and Polymarket received similar orders and have also sued the commission.

Novig argues that Ohio's sports betting laws are pre-empted by the Commodity Exchange Act and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's oversight of event contracts, and that the state's threatened enforcement is unconstitutional.

Central to the filing is Novig's contention that the Sixth Circuit's September ruling for Ohio and Tennessee against Kalshi, in KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler, is not settled law. Counsel for Novig wrote that "Schuler is not final: a petition for rehearing en banc is pending before the Sixth Circuit, and three petitions for certiorari presenting the same preemption question are pending before the Supreme Court."

Novig points to a CFTC interim final rule, together with a notice of proposed rulemaking issued on 9 October, as confirmation that sports-related event contracts are swaps falling under the commission's exclusive jurisdiction. It claims this rulemaking undermines the basis of the Sixth Circuit's decision, which had found such contracts did not qualify as swaps.

The argument echoes a line Novig raised six days earlier in New York, where a federal judge dismissed its bid for a preliminary injunction against state authorities. In that ruling, Judge Colleen McMahon noted that the CFTC's proposed rulemaking treated sports-event contracts as swaps while its interim final rule excluded casino-style products, including sportsbook and casino-game wagering contracts, from that definition. McMahon wrote that the two positions "are inherently contradictory and cannot be reconciled."

Novig's Ohio complaint also revives a Commerce Clause argument first advanced by Polymarket in its own suit against the state. It contends that Ohio's licensing regime, under which applicants must maintain a business presence within the state or strike a deal with an Ohio-based operator, discriminates against interstate commerce and would force Novig to restructure its operations to serve Ohio residents.

Joshua Kirschner, a partner and deputy team leader of the gaming practice at Holland & Knight, told SBC Americas last month that this commerce-based challenge to the OCCC's framework "seems to miss the point on a few counts."

Ohio's prediction markets litigation now spans multiple operators, with the OCCC facing parallel suits from Kalshi, Polymarket and Novig over the same underlying dispute: whether federally regulated event contracts on sport can be treated as unlicensed gambling under state law.