ECJ avoids ruling on Malta's Bill 55 gambling law again
The European Court of Justice declared a referral over Malta's Bill 55 inadmissible, leaving the law's compatibility with EU rules unresolved as a fresh case awaits a hearing.

The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has sidestepped a ruling on whether Malta's Bill 55 complies with EU law, dismissing a referral from an Austrian court as inadmissible, iGaming Business reported.
The case stemmed from action by Spielerschutz Sigma, an Austrian litigation funder that had won judgments from Austrian courts on behalf of players seeking refunds of gambling losses from Maltese-licensed operators that took bets without local authorisation in Austria.
Malta refused to recognise one of those Austrian judgments, prompting an Austrian court to ask the ECJ to rule on Bill 55, the 2023 law that blocks Maltese recognition and enforcement of foreign judgments arising from claims tied to activity in unlicensed markets abroad.
The ECJ ruled on Thursday that the underlying dispute did not actually require it to interpret EU law. Spielerschutz Sigma had sued a legal adviser over an opinion that Bill 55 was incompatible with EU law and would not apply to Maltese enforcement proceedings, and the court found that dispute fell outside its remit.
Terence Cassar, partner at Maltese law firm GTG, told iGaming Business the referral was built on shaky foundations. "It was very clear that the underlying case from which the referral was presented... This was essentially a legal malpractice lawsuit," he said, adding that a court can only decide on the matter put before it.
Felix Hohenthanner of Austrian firm Rapani Rechtsanwälte said the outcome was anticipated. "There were rumours that it was a made-up case, only for the reference to the ECJ," he said, noting the court lacked the procedural basis to take the case further.
Cassar rejected the suggestion that Bill 55 conflicts with EU rules on mutual recognition of court judgments between member states. "Malta's position on this point has been the same for more than 20 years at this stage," he said, describing it as a public policy stance dating back to the country's EU accession, which member states are entitled to adopt.
For Austrian players pursuing losses, the practical picture remains largely unchanged. Hohenthanner said recovery is becoming increasingly difficult where operators hold no assets outside Malta, leaving claimants with few options if Maltese enforcement is blocked.
Simon Priglinger-Simader, president of the Austrian Association for Betting and Gaming (OVWG), called Thursday's decision "understandable from an EU law perspective" and said the association would keep monitoring developments and their implications for members and player claims in Austria.
A separate route to a definitive ruling may already be open. Malta's Court of Appeal referred its own questions on Bill 55's compatibility with EU law to the ECJ in October, a case Hohenthanner believes could finally force the court to rule on the substance. "This will be the case where the CGU will decide on the merits on Bill 55, in my opinion," he said, suggesting a decision could land in 2027 or later.
The ECJ ruled in April that EU member states can take legal action against operators that breach their national gambling laws, a point regularly cited in the wider debate over Bill 55's standing against EU law.