CJEU throws out Austrian case against Malta's Bill 55 on technicality
The EU's top court ruled the Austrian reference in the Spielerschutz Sigma case inadmissible, leaving Malta's player-loss shield intact and the question of its legality with the European Commission.

Judges at the Court of Justice of the European Union have sidestepped the question of whether Malta's Bill 55 complies with EU law, dismissing a reference from an Austrian court on procedural grounds.
They concluded that the Vienna court could resolve the dispute in front of it without an answer on compatibility, since that case concerned a legal adviser's liability to Austrian litigation funder Spielerschutz Sigma rather than a player-loss claim itself.
That adviser had given an opinion, dated 5 July 2023, describing Article 56A of Malta's Gaming Act as manifestly contrary to EU law, and had expected first-instance enforcement proceedings in Malta to conclude within six months.
Events moved differently. On 1 August 2023, a Maltese court invoked Article 56A to refuse recognition and enforcement of a judgment under the Brussels I bis Regulation, in proceedings that Spielerschutz Sigma had funded.
Bill 55 inserted Article 56A into the Gaming Act in June 2023. Malta's government told the Luxembourg court that the provision is merely declaratory, intended to help domestic judges apply the public policy exception found in the Brussels I bis Regulation's Article 45(1)(a).
The case had followed an Advocate General opinion delivered in April that took a view on the merits. Because the reference failed on admissibility, the judges never had to address that alternative analysis.
For operators licensed by the Malta Gaming Authority with exposure in Germany, Austria and Switzerland, the ruling means no change. Maltese courts retain the ability to refuse enforcement of Austrian and German judgments ordering repayment of player losses, even as thousands of such claims continue to be pursued with the backing of litigation financiers.
Spielerschutz Sigma itself has already secured numerous judgments against Malta-licensed operators and is seeking to enforce them within Malta.
Two other recent CJEU rulings touch the same dispute from different angles. On 16 April 2026, in Case C-440/23, the Court found that member states are entitled to prohibit specific online gambling services even where they are licensed elsewhere in the bloc, and may attach civil-law consequences to that prohibition.
A separate ruling on 21 May 2026, in the Mr Green case, C-198/24, dealt with European Account Preservation Orders. The judges found that when assessing urgency, a court can take account of legislation in the debtor's home jurisdiction that might stand in the way of enforcement. That case concerned accounts held by a Malta-licensed operator in Ireland, Luxembourg, Malta and Sweden.
The underlying legal question around Bill 55's compatibility with EU law therefore remains unresolved. The European Commission's own infringement procedure concluded that the Maltese law required domestic courts to systematically refuse recognition and enforcement of other member states' judgments against Malta-licensed gaming companies, and said this undermined mutual trust in the administration of justice across the bloc.
CasinoBeats reported that earlier coverage had suggested the Commission was waiting for this judgment before deciding how to proceed. With the CJEU declining to rule, any further escalation of the infringement case now rests entirely with Brussels.