The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

CJEU declines to rule on Malta's Bill 55 EU compatibility

Europe's top court has sent a long-running dispute over Malta's gambling liability shield back to Vienna without settling whether the law complies with EU rules.

Court of Justice of the European Union building, linked to Malta's Bill 55 gambling law case
AI-generated illustration

The Court of Justice of the European Union has declined to issue a final ruling on whether Malta's Bill 55 is compatible with EU law, according to SBC News.

The decision leaves unresolved a question that has been building for three years, centred on Austrian players who lost money on gambling platforms licensed in Malta but operating outside Austria's own licensed regime.

Malta passed Bill 55 in 2023 as an amendment to its Gambling Act. The law shields the country's licensed operators from lawsuits brought in foreign European courts, resting on the EU's free trade principle, which Malta argues guarantees its licensed businesses unobstructed access to other member states' markets.

That protection put Malta on a collision course with Austria, where players began pursuing legal action against Maltese-licensed operators to recover losses accumulated on sites not authorised under Austria's own gambling framework.

A company called Spielerschutz Sigma, which translates as Player Protection Sigma, has been central to that push, covering some of the upfront legal costs for Austrian gamblers seeking compensation.

Soon after Bill 55 was introduced, Spielerschutz worked with an Austrian legal entity to obtain an assessment of the new law's validity. That assessment reportedly concluded that Bill 55 conflicts with established EU law and should not be applied by Maltese courts.

Armed with that assessment, Spielerschutz pressed ahead with supporting players' claims. Maltese courts, however, invoked Bill 55 to reject the claims and block enforcement against the operators.

Spielerschutz then turned on the law firm that had produced the original assessment, filing a complaint with the Commercial Court of Vienna alleging professional negligence and seeking financial compensation.

The Vienna court referred the underlying question to the CJEU in 2024, asking the EU's top court directly whether Bill 55 complies with European law.

The CJEU has now sent the case back to Vienna without issuing that ruling, stating that the Bill 55 compliance question is not relevant to resolving the professional negligence dispute before the Austrian court.

SBC News notes that the matter is far from settled, with players in Germany also currently pursuing compensation claims against Maltese-licensed operators, meaning the underlying legal question over Bill 55's standing under EU law remains open for future litigation.