The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

CFTC Nominees Dodge Questions on Sports Prediction Market Status

Nathan Anonick and Matthew Rowland declined to say whether sports event contracts amount to gambling, as Senator Adam Schiff accused CFTC Chairman Michael Selig of misleading Congress.

Capitol building representing the Senate Agriculture Committee hearing on CFTC nominees
AI-generated illustration

Two nominees to the Commodity Futures Trading Commission avoided taking a position on whether sports prediction markets amount to gambling during a Senate Agriculture Committee hearing on Tuesday, according to Legal Sports Report.

Nathan Anonick, nominated as a Republican commissioner, and Matthew Rowland, nominated as a Democrat, both declined to say whether trading on a sporting outcome through a prediction market should be regulated as sports betting.

Lawsuits have been filed nationwide challenging the CFTC's assertion that it holds sole federal authority over sports event contracts, a dispute now central to the nominees' testimony. That claimed authority has allowed platforms such as Kalshi and Polymarket to expand into states where traditional sports betting remains restricted or unlicensed.

That expansion has driven sharp rises in company valuations and prompted established operators including DraftKings and FanDuel to build their own competing prediction market products.

Senator Tina Smith pressed both nominees on whether any practical difference exists between a sports wager and a sports event contract. Rowland said he was 'certainly very sympathetic to the concerns that the states and tribes have raised' but said active litigation made it 'hard for me to comment' on the underlying legal question.

Anonick gave a similar answer when Senator Adam Schiff asked whether trading on Thursday's NFL game between the Indianapolis Colts and Houston Texans constituted sports betting, saying federal courts 'have disagreed on that' and that he did not want to 'tip the scales.' He said that, if confirmed, he would seek input from attorneys, state officials, tribes and other interested parties before settling on a view.

Schiff used the hearing to attack CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, recalling Selig's own confirmation testimony last year in which he pledged to let the courts settle whether sports event contracts are gambling. Schiff said Selig has instead taken an active role defending the agency's claimed jurisdiction through litigation against states and filings backing prediction market operators.

"I don't know whether he was just lying to us or once he was confirmed he had some kind of an epiphany, but he has been anything but a blank slate," Schiff said, adding that Selig 'has not looked to the courts' but has 'filed briefs to tell the courts what to do.'

Schiff also pointed to a 5 November directive from Selig instructing exchanges to lift certain geographic restrictions within 30 days, which he characterised as the chairman telling companies to disregard adverse court rulings and state or tribal law. A letter demanding the directive's reversal was sent to Selig on Monday, signed by Schiff along with eight other Democratic senators.

The hearing also touched on staffing cuts and reduced enforcement at the CFTC as its remit grows to cover more retail traders and prediction market activity. Rowland, who has spent years working at the CFTC, argued that the agency's enforcement program needed rebuilding and its staffing levels restoring, while Anonick said he would review staffing and identify where additional resources were needed if confirmed.

The two nominations came from President Trump just nine days after the midterm elections handed Democrats control of Congress, a point almost two years into his second term at which the bulk of the commission's five seats had remained unfilled. Federal law caps commissioners from the same political party at three, and Selig has served as the CFTC's sole commissioner since December 2025.

The committee took no vote on either nominee on Tuesday, leaving both nominations pending as the Senate weighs confirmation before the end of the year.