CFTC Order Bars Geofencing, Deepening Clash With State Regulators
A new CFTC directive says federally regulated exchanges cannot block users by state, setting prediction market operators against court orders in Michigan, Nevada and elsewhere.

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission has told designated contract markets they can no longer restrict access by state, a move that could force prediction market operators into direct conflict with court orders already in place in several jurisdictions.
The commission said Thursday that DCMs must provide what Chairman Michael Selig described as "competitive, open, fair, and impartial access to their members and persons with trading privileges" under existing federal rules, according to Legal Sports Report.
Selig said derivatives markets must function uniformly across the country to meet the goals of the Commodity Exchange Act, arguing that geographic restrictions clash with the law's impartial access requirements.
That interpretation lands at an awkward moment for the industry. Michigan and Nevada have already obtained injunctions barring sports-related contracts from trading within their borders, and the CFTC's position now appears to put compliance with federal rules on a collision course with those state orders.
DCMs have 30 days to end any domestic geographic restrictions that breach the Impartial Access Requirements, or to submit to the Division of Market Oversight an explanation of why compliance is not feasible. The same window applies to ensuring intermediaries accessing the markets meet the standard. The CFTC said it would weigh the facts of individual cases before deciding on any further action.
The legal landscape was already contested before Thursday's announcement. New Jersey has asked the Supreme Court to resolve the dispute after two appellate courts reached opposite conclusions on Kalshi's ability to offer sports contracts, and Arkansas this week became the latest state to sue the company.
DraftKings chief executive Jason Robins addressed the CFTC's move during an earnings call on Friday, saying he expects the courts to ultimately settle the question of prediction markets' legality. "We've managed to stay completely out of the litigation everywhere," he said, adding that most states appear to be waiting on judicial rulings before taking firmer action.
Robins played down the significance of the CFTC directive for DraftKings specifically. "As far as the CFTC thing, I wouldn't make anything of that," he said, noting there is an established process for demonstrating why an operator can only run in certain geographies and that the company has "had a really good relationship with the CFTC." DraftKings is separately being sued by the Seminole Tribe over its prediction market offerings in Florida, where the tribe holds a monopoly on online sports betting through Hard Rock Bet.
Benjamin Schiffrin, director of securities policy at Better Markets, took a sharply different view, accusing the commission of pushing operators toward defying court rulings. "Yesterday, the CFTC took its lawlessness to a whole new level," he said, arguing the agency has disregarded state gambling laws by treating sports event contracts as legitimate financial products.
Schiffrin said a federal appellate court in New York had already declined to stop state gambling authorities enforcing their laws against prediction markets, and predicted the CFTC's stance would push operators such as Kalshi toward geofencing users in New York, Connecticut and other states rather than risk breaching court orders.
He went further in criticising Selig personally. "Unfortunately, CFTC Chair Mike Selig thinks he is above the law," Schiffrin said, adding that the chairman was reacting to the industry's recent courtroom losses rather than resolving the underlying legal conflict.
The sector's sports-related contracts have also drawn bipartisan criticism in Washington over the past few years, adding political pressure to the mounting legal disputes between federal regulators and the states.