The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Underdog sues Missouri over prediction markets enforcement threat

The fantasy sports operator turned prediction markets firm has taken Missouri to federal court, the eighth state it has sued over cease-and-desist action.

St. Louis, Missouri skyline, where Underdog has filed a federal lawsuit against the state
AI-generated illustration

Underdog has sued Missouri in federal court, accusing the state's attorney general of threatening imminent enforcement action against its sports prediction markets business.

The lawsuit, filed on Sunday 8 November in the US District Court for the Western District of Missouri, was reported by SBC Americas. It claims Attorney General Catherine Hanaway's office told Underdog on Friday 6 November that the state intended to begin unspecified enforcement action within three days.

Underdog is seeking a preliminary injunction to block Missouri from acting against it while the case proceeds, arguing that further state intervention would cause serious and irreparable harm to its business.

The dispute traces back to cease-and-desist letters Hanaway's office sent to several operators in September, which told companies including Underdog to either stop offering sports wagering in Missouri or secure a licence from the Missouri Gaming Commission. The original deadline of 17 October was later pushed back to 30 October.

Counsel for Underdog described the position as a "Hobson's choice" in the filing, arguing that both routes open to the company would inflict damage on its operations.

The company also warned that enforcement would expose it to "civil penalties, potential criminal liability, forced cessation of operations in Missouri, and severe collateral consequences to its nationwide operations," according to the lawsuit. SBC Americas said it had contacted Hanaway's office for comment but had not received a response by the time of publication.

Underdog is not the only prediction markets operator to challenge Missouri in court. Crypto.com, Kalshi and Novig, which also received cease-and-desist letters alongside Robinhood and Polymarket, have each sued Hanaway's office. Kalshi argued in a late-October filing that Missouri's demand is unworkable because the state's two untethered sports wagering licences are held by DraftKings and Circa Sports, leaving remaining allocations tied to partnerships with a casino or a professional sports team. A spokesperson for Hanaway's office previously told SBC Americas the attorney general is confident federal courts will not stop her enforcing state law against Kalshi and its rivals.

PrizePicks, another operator that moved from daily fantasy sports into prediction markets, did not receive a Missouri cease-and-desist letter but chose to stop offering sports event contracts in the state regardless.

Underdog began offering prediction markets in September 2025 through a partnership with Crypto.com. It acquired the CFTC-registered exchange Aristotle Exchange in March, then brought its own exchange platform to market that July. According to an IG Group investor presentation cited this year, the firm expects prediction markets to climb from a 14% share of its total handle in 2025 to 46% in 2026, rising further to around 99% after 2027.

Missouri is the eighth state Underdog has sued, following Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Mexico, Ohio, Tennessee, Washington and Wisconsin. The company is separately set to be acquired by IG Group in a deal valued at $1.3bn.

Stacie Stern, who leads government affairs and partnerships for Underdog, told SBC Americas that litigation is sometimes "the only way to resolve a dispute" when operators and regulators each believe they are acting lawfully. "With cases and divergent rulings across the country, everyone can see what's happening in our industry: it's a mess," she said, adding that the industry needs the Supreme Court to settle whether a single federal standard or state-by-state regulation applies.

Founder and chief executive Jeremy Levine said during an October IG Group shareholder seminar that Underdog would be positioned to succeed whatever the Supreme Court ultimately decides on sports event contracts, including a fallback to player-only fantasy markets should the courts side with state regulators.