South Africa weighs appeal as lottery operator misses sales target
Trade minister Parks Tau has yet to decide whether to challenge a court ruling that voided Sizekhaya Holdings' national lottery licence, as regulator data shows ticket sales well below forecast.

A court ruling that overturned Parks Tau's award of South Africa's national lottery licence to Sizekhaya Holdings has yet to prompt a decision from the trade minister on whether to appeal, he told MPs.
Tau made the comments at a sitting of Parliament's Portfolio Committee on Trade, Industry and Competition held on 10 November, eight days after the court handed down its ruling. The broadcaster EWN quoted him telling the committee: "The matter is currently under consideration in the department. We have to define what the way forward is, taking into account the rulings of the court."
At the same hearing, the National Lotteries Commission disclosed that Sizekhaya's ticket sales were running well short of the figures in its winning bid, iGaming Business reported.
NLC executive manager Tintswalo Nkuna said Sizekhaya had projected around R3.5 billion in ticket sales but had generated R2.1bn, a shortfall of 39% against the bid and 21.7% below the regulator's revised 2026–27 forecast. Nkuna said the NLC had expected some dip in sales, since a new operator typically takes time to win over players' confidence. Sizekhaya had taken charge of the lottery on 1 June 2026, succeeding Ithuba Holdings, the operator that had run it across the previous 11 years.
The legal challenge that led to this month's ruling was brought by Ithuba Lottery and a rival bidder, Ringeta Consortium.
In the original tender, evaluators placed Ringeta top of the field on 73.92 points, with Sizekhaya a close second on 72.95, and an NLC board committee had put forward Ringeta as its recommended winner. Tau instead set up a separate ministerial committee to reassess the bids, which recommended Sizekhaya.
Judge Norman Davis found that this ministerial committee had run what he called a "parallel process" that re-scored the bids outside the rules of the tender. He noted that Tau's own reasons "often followed the Ministerial Committee's recommendations word for word." While Davis accepted that Tau had acted in good faith, he ruled that establishing and relying on the committee was "unlawful and procedurally unfair."
The court did reject a separate argument from Ithuba that Sizekhaya lacked fully committed funding at the point it won the licence.
The ruling does not prevent Sizekhaya from winning the licence again. The existing licence agreement has been declared invalid, and Tau must reconsider the award without reference to the ministerial committee's report. Sizekhaya may continue operating the lottery for up to a year while that happens. A fresh decision is due from Tau within six months, followed by a further six-month window to conclude a new agreement or, if necessary, hand the licence to another operator.
NLC chair Tembinkosi Bonakele stood by the minister's choice to gather further input before deciding the award. "It is fair to say, without criticising the judiciary, that there are some contradictions as to how the process should be managed, at least by the minister," he said.
Bonakele said Tau had wanted to examine issues a written bid does not easily reveal, citing "things like probity, things like BEE [Black Economic Empowerment], things like whether the games were properly defined as lottery games."
The licence award has been politically contentious since it was first made. Opposition parties have questioned a minority stake in Sizekhaya held through Bellamont Gaming, a firm co-owned by the sister of Deputy President Paul Mashatile's wife. Sizekhaya has rejected suggestions that political influence played a role in the award.
According to Bonakele, the NLC board is still waiting on the minister to say whether he will take the ruling to appeal.