The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Senators order CFTC to preserve records on prediction market rule

Nine Democratic senators have demanded the CFTC withdraw its geofencing interpretation and preserve all related communications since January 2025, a move one former agency lawyer calls a likely precursor to investigation.

US Capitol building, representing the Senate letter sent to the CFTC over prediction markets
AI-generated illustration

Nine Democratic senators sent the Commodity Futures Trading Commission a letter on Monday demanding it reverse its recent interpretation barring prediction market operators from geofencing certain states and tribal lands.

The most consequential part of the letter may not be that demand itself but its closing instruction: CFTC Chairman Michael Selig must preserve every record and communication tied to prediction markets dating back to 1 January 2025.

The office of California Senator Adam Schiff released the preservation order, which extends to personal email accounts, mobile devices, encrypted messaging apps and disappearing-message platforms. Anyone acting on the agency's behalf, formally or not, falls within its scope as well. Kalshi began offering sports-related contracts around that same January 2025 date, ahead of the Super Bowl.

Braden Perry, who previously worked as a senior trial attorney at the CFTC and is now a co-founding partner at Kennyhertz Perry LLC, said: "A letter from senators is not a subpoena, and it has no legal force on its own. But it puts the agency on notice." He added, "If records go missing later, no one at the CFTC can say they did not know to keep them."

Perry added that the request "reads like a first step toward something bigger."

Schiff, who sits on the Senate Agriculture Committee with oversight of the CFTC, led the letter. Every senator representing California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington signed it, including Alex Padilla, Elissa Slotkin, Gary Peters, Catherine Cortez Masto, Jacky Rosen, Maria Cantwell and Patty Murray. Senate Agriculture Committee ranking member Amy Klobuchar also added her name. The senators gave Selig a week to respond, including written confirmation that preservation is underway.

Channels that echoed past Wall Street fines

The preservation demand spans calendar entries, meeting notes, voicemails, texts and social media, and instructs the agency to switch off any auto-delete settings. Perry said the choice of channels was deliberate.

"Personal email, encrypted apps, and disappearing messages are the same channels the CFTC fined Wall Street banks hundreds of millions of dollars for using," he said. "Now the agency is being asked to meet the standard it enforced. That is not an accident."

Between December 2021 and August 2023 the CFTC levied more than $1bn in penalties against 18 financial institutions over employees' use of unapproved messaging channels, warning at the time that firms failing on recordkeeping do so "at their own peril."

Perry said the letter's reach into outside parties and its January 2025 starting point point to a broader question: who influenced the geofencing policy, and when.

Control of both chambers of Congress will shift to Democrats in January 2027 following the midterms, and gaming industry lawyers have told SBC Americas that heightened scrutiny of prediction markets is likely once that happens. Stephen Piepgrass, a partner at Troutman Pepper Locke, said investigating perceived regulatory overreach at the CFTC is already flagged as a priority, particularly given what lawmakers see as close industry ties amid the agency's clashes with individual states.

The legal hook behind the request

Piepgrass noted that senators cannot simply go fishing for wrongdoing; any inquiry needs a legal trigger. That trigger, in this case, is the CFTC's 5 November rule interpretation stating that geographic access restrictions are inconsistent with the Commodity Exchange Act and the Commission's own rules. The agency gave designated contract markets 30 days to drop geofencing or justify to its Division of Market Oversight why they could not.

Schiff responded publicly, describing the guidance as "the CFTC's most egregious attempt yet to undermine state law, the Tribes, and now, the courts."

In Monday's letter, the senators branded the interpretation a "unilateral decision" and said it "directly conflicts with active court orders," pointing to rulings that required platforms to halt certain contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, as well as land held by two California tribes. They argued the agency now seems to be pushing prediction markets toward defying those rulings while the litigation continues.