The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Kalshi faces New York show-cause order after case returns to state court

Attorney General Letitia James has asked a state judge to make Kalshi justify why her $36bn enforcement action should not proceed, after a federal judge sent the dispute back to New York's courts.

Exterior of a New York State courthouse associated with the Kalshi enforcement case
AI-generated illustration

A federal judge has remanded Kalshi's New York case back to state court, clearing the way for Attorney General Letitia James to press ahead with a $36bn enforcement action against the prediction markets operator.

Judge Vernon Broderick of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York ordered the remand on Thursday, rejecting Kalshi's attempt to move the dispute into the federal judiciary on the grounds that it falls under the jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC).

James responded on Friday with a filing in New York's Supreme Court asking Judge Melissa Crane to issue a show-cause order. That would require Kalshi to demonstrate why the court should not grant a temporary restraining order, and eventually preliminary and permanent injunctions, against its New York operations, according to SBC Americas.

The filing accuses Kalshi of "operating an unlawful gambling business, or otherwise advancing gambling activity or profiting from gambling activity, within or from New York or to persons in New York, without being licensed by the New York State Gaming Commission." It points specifically to users under the age of 21 accessing the platform and to marketing aimed at college and university campuses in the state.

The remand followed the US Second Circuit Court of Appeals' refusal two weeks earlier to grant Kalshi an injunction pending appeal of the state's planned enforcement. Kalshi first lost an attempt to block James's action on 26 July, and the attorney general launched her pursuit of the company five days later.

James's demand seeks far more than injunctive relief. It calls for a full accounting of every customer account, including itemised bet lists and total amounts won or lost, restitution to customers who lost money through Kalshi, and disgorgement of profits. It also seeks a penalty of "three times the amount of its gain" plus fines of $100,000 "for each offering or attempt to offer sports wagering or mobile sports wagering within or from New York without authorization." Those demands underpin the headline $36bn figure from James's original July action, filed a day after Kalshi's Second Circuit defeat.

A Kalshi spokesperson struck a softer tone than in previous exchanges with the state, saying the company wants to work with New York officials on a resolution that protects the interests of its 1.2 million users in the state, according to SBC Americas.

The remand and show-cause filing come as CFTC Chair Michael Selig pushes back against state-level action on prediction markets more broadly. His agency is currently suing a dozen states over their efforts to regulate the sector. "My door is always open to talk to governors and attorneys general who want to discuss legal or policy concerns," Selig said. "But jurisdictional disagreements should be settled through constructive dialogue, not by threatening American businesses."

Kalshi's difficulties in New York extend beyond the enforcement action. James filed a separate suit earlier this month to force the company to comply with subpoenas issued in August over alleged deceptive marketing, centred on payments to influencers promoting the platform.

The New York City Council also opened an investigation in August into Kalshi and other prediction markets operators, citing "allegations of predatory marketing practices associated with the prediction market industry."