Kalshi loses Fourth Circuit appeal over Maryland sports contracts ban
A divided appeals panel sided with Maryland regulators against the prediction markets operator, marking Kalshi's third defeat in four federal circuit rulings.

A three-judge panel of the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled 2-1 against Kalshi on Tuesday, upholding Maryland's position in a dispute over whether the operator's sports event contracts count as swaps under the Commodity Exchange Act.
The ruling marks Kalshi's third loss in four federal circuit court appeals, according to SBC Americas. The company had already lost unanimously at the Sixth and Ninth Circuits.
Judge Roger Gregory, appointed by Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush, wrote the lead concurrence. He said gambling regulation has long sat within state police power and that he would not infer Congress displaced Maryland's authority without a clear statement of intent to do so.
Gregory added that Kalshi had not shown compliance with both the CEA and Maryland law to be impossible, nor that state law obstructs Congress's aim of a centralised federal framework for derivatives trading. He concurred in affirming the district court's judgment.
Judge Stephanie Thacker, an Obama appointee, joined the majority outcome but arrived there differently. She wrote that Congress defined swaps and placed them under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's exclusive jurisdiction through the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, passed in response to the 2008 financial crisis to improve accountability and transparency in the financial system.
Thacker said that purpose "has nothing to do with sports betting" and concluded that Kalshi's sports-based contracts are not swaps at all, a separate basis for affirming the lower court.
Judge DeAndrea Gist Benjamin, appointed by President Biden, dissented. She wrote that prediction markets and swaps have clearly grown more prevalent, but that Congress's command giving the CFTC exclusive jurisdiction over swaps has not changed. Because she views Kalshi's sports-related contracts as swaps, she would have found Maryland's laws field preempted.
Kalshi seized on the division among the three judges to attack the ruling. A company statement provided to media argued that judges "can't agree with each other on why we're wrong," pointing to three separate, contradictory opinions as evidence that no unified legal argument exists against prediction markets.
The company could seek an en banc rehearing at the Fourth Circuit, as it has pursued after previous losses at that level, per SBC Americas.
The outcome contrasts with Kalshi's lone appellate win, delivered by the Third Circuit in April, when a panel ruled 2-1 that New Jersey gaming regulators could not bar the firm's sports event contracts. CEO Tarek Mansour did not dwell on that split at the time, instead calling it on social media "a big win for the industry" that reflected markets that are "more fair, transparent, and reward being right." Co-founder Luana Lopes Lara marked the New Jersey victory on social media as well, joking about visiting the Jersey Shore that day.
The split decisions across circuits leave Kalshi's underlying legal question, whether federal commodities law preempts state gambling regulation of sports event contracts, unresolved nationally, with the company now 1-3 in appellate rulings on the issue.