The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Jake's 58 Cashier Sues Casino Over Tip Pool Skimming

A former cage worker at Jake's 58 Casino alleges managers took a cut of a tip pool shared by roughly 50 hourly staff, then fired him after he complained.

Exterior signage at Jake's 58 Casino in New York, the subject of a tip pooling lawsuit
AI-generated illustration

A former cage cashier at Jake's 58 Casino has filed a federal lawsuit accusing the New York property of letting managers and supervisors skim money from a tip pool reserved for hourly workers.

The suit, filed in the Eastern District of New York by plaintiff Kevin Guttinger, alleges the casino required tipped employees to contribute to a shared pool that management then administered — taking a portion for themselves before distributing what remained through payroll.

Guttinger worked at Jake's 58 from March 2022 until November 1, 2024. He claims he was dismissed in retaliation for challenging the arrangement, and says he raised the issue formally with upper management on February 16, 2024.

According to the complaint, the pool at times exceeded $50,000 in a single week and was shared among roughly 50 employees. Guttinger alleges there was no transparency over how the money was divided, and that some supervisors acknowledged their own participation in the pool might be unlawful.

The federal Fair Labor Standards Act, signed into law in 1938, bars employers, managers and supervisors from keeping any share of tips earned by employees, whether or not those workers are paid under a tip credit arrangement. The Department of Labor states the prohibition applies regardless of how the employer structures wages for tipped staff.

Jake's 58, which is owned and operated by Suffolk OTB, offers around 1,000 slot-like video lottery terminals and is in the middle of a $210 million expansion expected to double its number of gaming positions.

Guttinger's role as a cage cashier involved handling vouchers, tickets and cash rather than working a traditional gaming floor position where tipping is routine. Gratuities at the cage typically come from gamblers cashing out large wins or requiring time-consuming transactions such as sorting large stacks of chips. Despite the irregular nature of cage tipping, Guttinger was required to contribute what he received to the shared pool.

The lawsuit seeks class-action status to cover other similarly affected employees, along with reimbursement of allegedly withheld tips, lost wages and benefits tied to Guttinger's claimed retaliatory firing.

Newsday first reported on the litigation and said Jake's 58 declined to comment beyond stating the matter would be addressed through the appropriate legal process.

The case follows other tip pooling disputes in the casino sector. Mount Airy Casino Resort in Pennsylvania's Pocono Mountains settled a comparable claim for $2.3 million in December 2025, while a similar lawsuit against Ocean Casino Resort in Atlantic City remains ongoing.