The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Casino

Evolution settles with law firm over Black Cube smear report

Casino games supplier reaches confidential deal with New Jersey firm that circulated a Playtech-funded report alleging sanctions breaches, as the underlying case against Black Cube continues.

Gavel and law books symbolising Evolution's New Jersey court settlement over a disputed gaming report
AI-generated illustration

Evolution has reached a settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky LLP, the New Jersey law firm that helped distribute a disputed 2021 report accusing the casino games supplier of operating in sanctioned markets.

Lawyers for the firm confirmed the agreement during a hearing in New Jersey Superior Court on Tuesday, according to a report by NEXT.io cited by Casino.org News. The deal removes Calcagni & Kanefsky as a party to Evolution's wider defamation lawsuit, which continues against Israeli private intelligence firm Black Cube.

The dispute traces back to an anonymous report, later attributed to Black Cube, alleging that Evolution's games were reaching jurisdictions subject to US sanctions, including Iran. Calcagni & Kanefsky passed the report to gaming regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania, prompting regulatory investigations and extensive media coverage at the time. Evolution's share price fell sharply, erasing billions from its market value.

Evolution has consistently denied the allegations and has characterised the report as part of a deliberate effort to damage its reputation and undercut its position against competitors.

Black Cube calls it a retreat

At Tuesday's hearing, Black Cube's lawyers asked the court for access to the settlement terms, arguing they could bear on the ongoing litigation. Evolution's counsel refused to disclose the agreement, citing confidentiality provisions. Judge John Porto suggested a separate court order might be needed before the terms could be released.

Black Cube's attorneys described the settlement as a "white flag of surrender" and said they believed it involved no financial payment to Evolution. Casino.org News noted that this claim has not been independently verified.

Black Cube is separately seeking to have Evolution's lawsuit thrown out under New Jersey's Uniform Public Expression Protection Act, a law intended to shield parties from suits aimed at discouraging legitimate public participation. The firm argues its investigation rested on genuine evidence and that flagging suspected regulatory breaches is protected activity. Evolution rejects that characterisation, maintaining the report was commercially motivated.

Playtech's role under scrutiny

The case shifted significantly in October 2025, when proceedings revealed that Playtech, one of Evolution's main rivals in the games supply market, had commissioned Black Cube to carry out the investigation. Evolution alleges Playtech orchestrated an anticompetitive campaign and concealed its involvement for years.

Playtech has acknowledged commissioning the Black Cube investigation but denies any wrongdoing, saying the resulting report raised legitimate concerns about Evolution's business conduct.

Evolution asked the court in April this year for permission to add Playtech and other parties as defendants. Judge Porto rejected that request without prejudice in June, ruling that Black Cube's UPEPA challenge should be resolved first before any expansion of the case.

The regulatory thread of the saga has already concluded. The New Jersey Division of Gaming Enforcement closed its own investigation into the original allegations in February 2024 without taking any action against Evolution, finding no evidence that the company had knowingly allowed or materially benefited from its products being offered in prohibited markets.