The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Casino

Evolution drops claim against law firm, Black Cube sole defendant

Evolution has settled its defamation case against Calcagni & Kanefsky, leaving Black Cube to fight New Jersey's anti-SLAPP law alone while a ruling could reopen the door to suing Playtech.

Gavel and legal documents representing the Evolution, Black Cube and Playtech New Jersey court case
AI-generated illustration

Evolution has reached a settlement with Calcagni & Kanefsky, the law firm that forwarded a Black Cube intelligence report to US gaming regulators, according to CasinoBeats, ending its defamation claim against the firm. The move leaves Black Cube as the sole remaining defendant in a case Evolution first filed in December 2021.

Counsel for Calcagni & Kanefsky disclosed the settlement as a hearing opened at the Atlantic County courthouse on Black Cube's bid to have the claim thrown out under New Jersey's anti-SLAPP statute, UPEPA. The terms of the settlement are confidential, and Black Cube's lawyers have asked the court to view them.

Black Cube is pursuing its challenge through an order to show cause. UPEPA allows a defendant to keep pressing for a ruling, and to seek costs and legal fees, even where a claimant withdraws a contested claim without prejudice.

Black Cube was drawn into the litigation gradually. The court ordered Calcagni & Kanefsky to identify the report's author in April 2025, and Black Cube was then named as a defendant by Evolution in mid-June that year. The New Jersey Superior Court went on to order Black Cube to name its client in September 2025.

Evolution has said the law firm passed the report to regulators in New Jersey and Pennsylvania in November 2021. It has also said Black Cube was paid more than £1.8 million by Playtech to produce the material.

The outcome of the UPEPA challenge carries weight beyond Black Cube's own position. A New Jersey judge earlier this year rejected Evolution's attempt to add PR executive Juda Engelmayer to the case, and Evolution intends to try again once the anti-SLAPP question is resolved.

If the claim against Black Cube survives the challenge, Evolution can renew its effort to sue Playtech directly, which would put the 2021 report back in front of licensing regulators and investors.

Playtech has rejected the allegations throughout. Its 2025 annual results defend the decision to commission the report and dispute the claims against it, and state that neither Playtech plc nor any of its subsidiaries had been served with a claim by the time those results were approved.

Playtech has also pushed back publicly. In a regulatory announcement on 9 September 2026, it said a separate Spectrum Report, commissioned by Evolution and filed in court by Black Cube, corroborates key elements of Black Cube's original investigation. Playtech pointed to findings on Evolution games appearing in prohibited markets, and said Spectrum concluded Evolution takes no proactive steps to verify whether operators using its products are complying with their contracts.

Black Cube's UPEPA challenge is now awaiting a decision from the court.