The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Business

Clase trial: jurors hear betting data on viral Pages strikeout

Testimony in Emmanuel Clase's Brooklyn fraud trial detailed how a losing swing by Andy Pages wiped out more than $11,000 in co-conspirator bets.

Baseball pitcher mid-delivery, referencing Emmanuel Clase betting fraud trial testimony
AI-generated illustration

Andy Pages is remembered for a game-saving catch in the deciding game of the 2025 World Series, but inside a Brooklyn federal courtroom he is better known for a swing that went nowhere.

The clip dates to an early-season meeting between the Los Angeles Dodgers and the Cleveland Guardians, with Cleveland ahead 7-4 in the top of the ninth. Pages swung at an 89 mile-per-hour Emmanuel Clase slider that bounced in the dirt, a strike that triggered a wave of losing microbets, according to iGaming Business.

One bettor, a Dominican Republic native living in New York, told the outlet's reporting on trial evidence that he lost $4,000 on that single pitch, his second significant loss betting on Clase over two years.

Clase, a two-time American League reliever of the year, is standing trial alongside fellow Guardians pitcher Luis Ortiz on charges of feeding advance information on pitch speed and outcome to bettors as part of a criminal conspiracy.

The government's star witness, Enthony Diaz, finished two days of testimony on Friday afternoon. He told jurors he received tips from a Clase associate who claimed the Pages and earlier Manny Machado wagers in 2023 were certain winners. Both bets lost.

Diaz fared far better betting on Ortiz. He testified to winning more than $30,000 on Ortiz-related wagers, some placed using information supplied by Enoc Pena, prosecutors allege.

Defense lawyers used his criminal history to challenge his credibility, pressing him on admitted bank and check fraud. A combative cross-examination gave way to an equally forceful redirect from prosecutors before jurors were dismissed for the weekend.

Earlier testimony from FBI Special Agent Noah Bilger, questioned by Assistant US Attorney Sean Sherman, walked jurors through a spreadsheet of more than a dozen co-conspirator bets tied to the Pages pitch. Every one of them lost, for a combined $11,028. Bilger told the court the pitch could not be scored a ball and none of the bettors won because the batter swung.

Richard Busick, an agent with the FBI's Cellular Analysis Survey Team, also testified. He previously gave cell-tower evidence on the whereabouts of FTX founder Sam Bankman-Fried's phone during the 2023 fraud trial. In this case, Busick used geolocation data to place Pena at Clase's residence at the same moment his DraftKings app recorded wagering activity.

Pena, who signed a cooperation agreement with prosecutors, is unlikely to be called as a witness, according to prosecutors. Defense attorneys have described him as unreliable, citing false information he gave on loan, immigration and tax documents.

Diaz's own credibility came under similar attack. Questioned by Elizabeth Geddes, an attorney representing Ortiz, Diaz admitted falsifying loan applications on at least five occasions and defrauding banks of at least $85,000.

He told the court he had given Pena the password to one bank account to keep a loan payment current while he travelled to the Dominican Republic, and separately gave him access to a Key Bank account, though he said he did not recall doing the same for an account at MCU Bank.

Shown a fictitious $4,221 check bearing his name, Diaz said he had never seen it before and added only that the bank had blocked his account when pressed further by Geddes.

On redirect, Assistant US Attorney Eric Silverberg had Diaz acknowledge the bank fraud while the witness remained vague about the disputed checks. Silverberg also noted Diaz was the single most profitable bettor on Ortiz pitches, netting at least $31,418 in 2025 across four regulated sportsbooks: DraftKings, FanDuel, ESPN BET and Caesars Sportsbook.

Diaz testified that Pena told Ortiz he had inside knowledge on four pitches believed to be rigged, two thrown by Clase and two by Ortiz himself, including the pitches against Pages and Machado that cost Diaz money.