Former Catcher Testifies at Emmanuel Clase Pitch-Rigging Trial
Bo Naylor told jurors in Brooklyn that pitches prosecutors say were rigged by Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz looked like normal baseball to him.

A former Cleveland Guardians catcher testified on Thursday that he noticed nothing unusual about pitches prosecutors allege were deliberately manipulated by two of his former teammates, Casino.org News reported.
Bo Naylor, who now plays for the Milwaukee Brewers, took the stand for the defense in the federal case against pitchers Emmanuel Clase and Luis Ortiz, who face conspiracy and fraud charges in a Brooklyn courtroom overseen by US District Judge Kiyo Matsumoto.
Prosecutors allege the two men took part in a betting scheme that generated at least $460,000 by deliberately influencing the outcome of individual pitches.
Shown footage of deliveries from the 2025 season, including pitches prosecutors say were intentionally thrown outside the strike zone, Naylor told jurors the sequences were consistent with ordinary game strategy, according to ESPN.
He explained that pitchers and catchers typically prepare by studying an opposing batter's weaknesses and agreeing in advance on pitch type and location, and said even elite pitchers cannot guarantee that every throw lands exactly where intended.
Questioned by Assistant US Attorney James Simmons, Naylor conceded that he had not realized gamblers could stake money on individual pitches until the investigation came to light publicly.
"I didn't know that until the situation," he testified, according to the Associated Press.
Such wagers, known as microbets, let bettors stake money on whether a single pitch will be called a ball or a strike, a market structure that creates openings for manipulation without necessarily affecting a game's final result.
Prosecutors contend Clase, a three-time All-Star, began feeding gamblers advance information on his pitches in 2023 before bringing Ortiz into the alleged scheme in 2025, with Clase accused of manipulating 18 pitches across 17 games and Ortiz accused of deliberately throwing two balls for payment.
Both men deny the charges against them and are currently sitting out the season on leave from the Guardians without pay.
Naylor was also questioned about clubhouse rumors concerning Clase's reported fondness for cockfighting, a pastime that carries no legal restriction in the Dominican Republic, Clase's home country.
Defense attorneys argue that messages prosecutors read as coded references to rigged pitches actually referred to cockfighting and dominoes, and they have sought to discredit Enoc Pena, the gambler prosecutors describe as central to the scheme, by arguing he exploited his relationship with Clase.
Investigators have separately presented betting records and geolocation data they say tie gambling activity to Clase's residence.
The trial is expected to continue into early December.