The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Betting News

Clase Pitch-Rigging Trial Opens With Fight Over Key Bettor

Opening statements in the federal bribery trial of Cleveland Guardians pitcher Emmanuel Clase centred on whether a bettor named Enoc Pena can be trusted, iGaming Business reports.

Cleveland Guardians pitcher Emmanuel Clase on the mound during an MLB game
AI-generated illustration

Opening statements began this week in the Brooklyn federal trial of Cleveland Guardians pitcher Emmanuel Clase, who faces charges of conspiracy to influence sporting contests by bribery, iGaming Business reported.

Clase, a two-time American League Reliever of the Year, is accused by prosecutors of rigging 18 pitches during the 2025 MLB season as part of a wider betting conspiracy. Fellow Guardians pitcher Luis Ortiz is accused of rigging two additional pitches. Both men were arrested last autumn and have maintained their innocence.

Assistant U.S. Attorney Rebecca Urquiola delivered the government's opening statement, accusing the pitchers of acting as "cheaters." Defence attorney Michael Bronson, representing Clase, told jurors the exchanges prosecutors have characterised as coded communication were in fact "ordinary conversations about rooster fighting," not "code words." Cockfighting, legal in the pitchers' native Dominican Republic, featured repeatedly in both sides' framing of the case.

The sharpest clash centred on a bettor named Enoc Pena, listed in court filings as a potential prosecution witness, and distinct from a separate figure identified in filings as "Bettor-1" who allegedly served as Clase's principal gambling contact. Samuel Landes, an attorney for Ortiz, told jurors Pena had lied on tax returns, loan applications and immigration forms. Government attorneys indicated in a hearing last week that they may choose not to call Pena at trial.

According to Landes, Pena placed more than 7,000 bets totalling at least $725,000. Prosecutors allege bettors connected to the scheme won at least $450,000 wagering on the rigged pitches. One associate linked to Clase wagered on the velocity of a single pitch more than 150 times, winning 98 of those bets - a 64.9% strike rate - for a net gain of roughly $95,000.

A superseding indictment dated 12 February 2026 states that Bettor-1 shared a screenshot of a conversation with Clase referencing "Chicken Number 3." In it, Clase wrote: "After I kill the first 2, play the 3," adding, "And if I can't kill it, don't play it. I have to kill the first 2." The defence maintains this refers to cockfighting; prosecutors call it coded language about pitch rigging.

Landes told jurors the government's case "sits on Pena," and "you can't trust Pena," warning that his absence from the stand would leave a "gaping hole" in the prosecution's case. Bronson separately described Pena as a compulsive gambler who deceived Clase. Urquiola did not mention Pena by name in her opening remarks, though prosecutors have signalled they will call a forensic accountant to testify that the defendants sought to conceal kickbacks. "The defendants actions are criminal and that's why we are here," Urquiola told the jury.

Prosecutors say all but one of the pitches allegedly rigged by Clase occurred in the regular season. The exception came in Game 1 of the 2024 American League Division Series against the Detroit Tigers, when Clase entered with a 7-0 lead in the ninth inning and threw an opening ball to Matt Vierling before closing the sequence with three straight strikes, two of them 100mph-plus cutters, to finish the game.

Milwaukee Brewers catcher Bo Naylor, who caught for the Guardians from 2022 to 2026 before an August trade, testified out of order as a defence witness on Thursday. Naylor recalled being caught off guard by the 93mph slider thrown to Vierling, which bounced off the dirt and his glove to the backstop, causing him to recoil. He also caught behind the plate for another pitch alleged by prosecutors to have been rigged.