The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Regulation

Brazilian deputy proposes bill forcing betting operators to repay losses

A bill from federal deputy Ricardo Abrão would make licensed Bets operators reimburse customer losses, drawing warnings of a legal aberration from Brazilian lawyers.

Brazilian Congress building, where a bill on betting operator refunds is under review
AI-generated illustration

Federal deputy Ricardo Abrão of the PSDB party in Rio de Janeiro has submitted a bill to Brazil's Chamber of Deputies that would force online betting operators to repay money lost by customers under the suspended Bets Law regime.

The bill, PL No. 5,502/2026, carries the title "Full Restitution and Compensation for Bettors Law". SBC Notícias Brasil reported that lawmakers sent it for review to two committees on 12 November: Consumer Protection, and Constitution, Justice and Citizenship.

Abrão's central aim is restitution. The bill would make operators liable for repaying customers' net losses recorded under the Bets regime, alongside obligations covering unpaid winnings and improperly withheld funds.

Licensed operators would also be required to provide customers with detailed transaction statements within ten working days. The bill sets out ten circumstances that would trigger reimbursement: these range from total net losses and balances never returned to customers, through to winnings left unpaid, bets that were cancelled and transactions made without authorisation.

Abrão has framed the proposal as fair retribution against a sector he says contributed to the "unchecked expansion of a market that has harmed vulnerable Brazilians, making repayment of customers' losses necessary". He argues operators and their controlling shareholders, not taxpayers, should bear the cost of a failed regime.

The bill follows the suspension of Brazil's online gambling market by President Lula's provisional measure, No. 1,394/2026, introduced on 25 September 2026. The Supreme Federal Court has since suspended lower-court proceedings challenging that ban, with Justice Luiz Fux presiding, and is expected to rule on its constitutionality. Congress must separately decide whether to convert the presidential order into permanent federal law.

Abrão has said the measure's suspension of operations gives the refund proposal its urgency, describing the situation as grounds for the bill's submission.

Lawyers reject the plan

Udo Seckelmann, a partner at the law firm Bichara e Motta Advogados, was swift to criticise the proposal, telling SBC Notícias Brasil it amounted to "a genuine legal aberration".

Seckelmann said the bill would force operators to return money lost through lawfully placed bets, ignoring that betting inherently involves risk. He distinguished this from holding companies accountable for fraud or contractual breaches, saying turning legitimate losses into a reimbursement obligation "subverts the legal rationale underpinning betting, undermines legal certainty and disregards the inherently uncertain nature of betting contracts".

He warned the financial and operational consequences could be "potentially devastating", with operators facing liabilities that could run into billions of reais, plus a near-impossible task: rebuilding the transaction history of every individual customer across a user base numbering in the millions, inside a tight deadline.

Asked whether the bill could pass, Seckelmann said political conditions might favour it given current pressure on the betting sector, but added that approval would run into serious constitutional obstacles, touching on principles such as legal certainty, proportionality, the freedom to conduct business and safeguards for contracts already lawfully concluded.

Seckelmann said consumer protection could not justify arbitrary financial obligations or disregard the nature of lawfully concluded contracts, and predicted that if the bill passed in its current form it would face legal challenge.