High Court dismisses negligence claim against Betfair over customer suicide
Mr Justice Swift ruled Betfair had no duty of care over Luke Ashton's gambling because the evidence did not establish he suffered from gambling disorder before his death.

The High Court of England and Wales has dismissed a negligence claim brought against Betfair over the death of customer Luke Ashton, SBC News reported.
Ashton, from Leicester, took his own life in April 2021 at the age of 40 following serious financial problems linked to his gambling. His widow, Ann Marie, and other relatives brought the case against the Flutter Entertainment-owned brand in 2024.
The family alleged that Betfair showed negligence in the systems and controls used to monitor Ashton's gambling between 2019 and 2021, and that the firm had failed to act on signs of a gambling disorder it ought to have recognised. SBC News reported the claimants' case was put on the basis that "in 2019 and in 2021 he did suffer from gambling disorder and that his behaviour was such that the Defendant ought to have known that he suffered from gambling disorder."
A debt of £18,000, uncovered in 2019, alerted Ann Marie Ashton to her husband's persistent gambling. In the year to April 2021, the couple's gross earnings combined came to just under £57,000.
Mr Justice Swift examined whether Ashton's betting activity across the Betfair Exchange, where he mainly staked on football and horse racing, should have triggered intervention. The judge found that losses, betting frequency and changes to deposit limits could not reliably establish his underlying motivations or confirm a gambling disorder. The court also noted that exchange betting tends to attract customers who put more time and planning, though not necessarily more money, into their wagering than typical sportsbook users.
Ashton's gambling did intensify between March and April 2021, when he deposited £7,000 and lost £5,600. He never requested self-exclusion from Betfair but did frequently adjust his deposit limits, moving from £10 up to £5,000. Betfair sent him four automated safer gambling messages in March 2021, prompted by his deposit activity and time spent on the platform.
The family's psychiatric expert, Dr John Baker, argued that Ashton's gambling disorder ran from April 2018 through to April 2021, deteriorating into a severe form as his death approached, with the claim focusing on June to July 2019 and January to April 2021. Ashton was never diagnosed during his lifetime, and Mr Justice Swift ruled that a retrospective diagnosis was not sufficiently supported by the evidence.
"Since there is insufficient evidence to support a conclusion that Mr Ashton suffered from gambling disorder the Claimants' claim must fail," the judge found. He added that it followed there was no sufficient evidence Betfair knew or ought to have known of a gambling disorder at any point between July 2019 and April 2021, meaning "the duty of care on which the Claimants' case must stand or fall did not arise."
Mr Justice Swift framed his ruling around the principle of adult autonomy. "Those who choose to gamble may make decisions that others may reasonably regard as poor choices, whether by choosing to gamble at all or in the way in which or extent to which they gamble," he said. "However, respect for personal autonomy requires respect for the freedom to act unwisely."
He concluded that an operator's duty of care should extend no further than preventing severe gambling disorder where that harm was reasonably foreseeable, a standard licensed firms including Betfair must monitor and record under the Gambling Act 2005 as enforced by the Gambling Commission.