The betting and iGaming industry, explained

Verte News

Edition: English

Casino

Third Claimant Joins Fight Over $12.8m Arizona Lottery Ticket

A customer who ordered but never paid for the winning Circle K tickets has entered a legal dispute between a fired store manager and the convenience chain.

A Circle K convenience store sign, the site of the disputed Arizona Lottery ticket sale
AI-generated illustration

A legal battle over a $12.8 million Arizona Lottery jackpot has grown more complicated after the customer who originally ordered the tickets joined the dispute, Casino.org News reported.

Court records cited by the outlet show Soonchun Kim entered the case in September, adding a third claimant to a fight already under way between former Circle K store manager Robert Gawlitza and his ex-employer.

On 24 November 2025, Kim approached a clerk at a Scottsdale Circle K wanting $85 worth of $1 tickets for The Pick, an Arizona Lottery draw game in which players try to match six numbers picked that evening. Realising she only had $60 on her, she left 25 of the tickets unpaid for at the store. One of them matched all six numbers in that night's draw.

Store manager Robert Gawlitza found the winning ticket among the unsold stock the next morning. Court filings state that he clocked out and swapped out of his work uniform before arranging for cashier Marline Ybarra to sell him the leftover tickets for $10, for which he kept a receipt. Court exhibits show he had texted his supervisor seeking approval to make the purchase, but did not mention that he had already discovered a winner until afterwards.

Gawlitza and Ybarra agreed to split any winnings equally. Circle K instead retained the ticket itself, dismissed Gawlitza from his job, and brought a lawsuit in February asking a court to rule on who is entitled to the prize money.

The company's case rests on Arizona Lottery rules that it says hand ownership of unsold tickets to the retailer, and on the argument that Gawlitza had no right to buy the winning ticket once the draw had already happened.

Gawlitza's attorney, Josh Kolsrud, says his client was following a longstanding, unwritten Circle K practice under which employees pay for mistakenly printed tickets that go unsold. Six current and former employees have submitted statements backing that account, Casino.org News reported.

Gawlitza has filed counterclaims against Circle K, including wrongful termination, and he and Ybarra also argue the company improperly held onto the winning ticket. The basis of Kim's claim has not been detailed in court filings reviewed by the outlet.

At a hearing on 6 November, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Joseph Kreamer allowed the underlying lawsuit to proceed but paused most of the employees' other claims, according to NBC Palm Springs. The court intends to first determine legal ownership of the ticket before any other issues are resolved.

A judge has already extended the deadline for claiming the prize to prevent the ticket from expiring while ownership remains contested.