Amelco trader says fixed odds could revive US horse racing handle
Stephen Bailey of pricing technology firm Amelco argues US racing needs fixed-odds betting to win over sportsbook-first bettors turned off by pari-mutuel pools.

US horse racing handle drops sharply once the Triple Crown and the Breeders' Cup finish, and Stephen Bailey, senior racing trader at pricing and trading technology provider Amelco, has set out why he believes fixed-odds wagering is the fix the sport needs, in comments reported by SBC Americas.
Bailey told the publication that the pari-mutuel tote model fails younger, sportsbook-first bettors because it lacks price certainty. Pool dividends shift up to and beyond the off, so a customer backing a horse at displayed odds of 4/1 can see that figure collapse to 2/1 once late money moves the pool, an experience he said feels like a broken contract to bettors used to fixed NFL moneylines.
Despite fixed odds being talked up as racing's saviour for five years, Bailey said state-by-state adoption in the US has been slow. He drew a parallel with historic resistance in UK racing, arguing that pari-mutuel operators built on legislative monopolies fear that fixed odds will cannibalise tote pools and track revenue, a mindset he said ignores how far sportsbook customers have already moved on.
Holding on to a tote model with roughly 20% takeout, he argued, is riskier long-term than capturing a share of high-volume fixed-odds sportsbook action, and he said regulators and tracks will eventually need to confront that.
On the industry's reluctance to move because of computer-assisted wagering (CAW) syndicates and sharp offshore money, Bailey acknowledged the threat is genuine but said it is manageable. He said CAW syndicates exploit pool mathematics in the final fractions before the gates open, whereas in a fixed-odds market the trading desk retains control, able to use automated risk tools to manage stakes, restrict smaller midweek tracks to singles, set liability limits and profile accounts in real time.
Asked how fixed odds and pari-mutuel pools could coexist without one eating into the other's revenue, Bailey said any significant gap between a fixed price and the tote creates an arbitrage opportunity for syndicates chasing off-market value. His answer is for sportsbooks to build independent pricing for smaller, high-frequency evening cards, which he said requires better access to live streaming, sectional times and automated form analysis. Done properly, he said, fixed odds would generate fresh recreational handle and channel commercial rights fees back to tracks rather than draining pool revenue.
On handling the pace of US racing, which runs across multiple time zones with dozens of meetings simultaneously, Bailey said Amelco's automated racing engine does the mathematical heavy lifting but still needs human traders watching live money, reacting to market swings and flagging issues during races. Technology handles the calculations, he said, while traders manage the broader risk picture, particularly around liability spikes and changing track conditions on major races.
Bailey also addressed how racing is presented within sportsbook apps, noting that the sport is often relegated to the back pages or left out altogether. He said turnover improves when fixed-odds racing sits alongside NFL and NBA markets rather than being siloed, and suggested simpler, quicker products such as boosted favourites and quick-fire doubles would help racing compete for attention on the same bet slip as major team sports.